
This was an easy five-star read for me.
I wondered whether Pastor Colby Martin could really add much beyond what he accomplished in UnClobber, a book that I found incredibly thoughtful and influential. I couldn’t have been more wrong. Rather than repeating himself, Martin builds on that foundation with fresh insights, more personal stories, and timely discussions—particularly around the transgender community and the questions many churches are wrestling with today.
As an affirming Lutheran Christian, I’ve believed for a long time that faith and LGBTQ inclusion belong together. Even so, I found myself highlighting passage after passage. Martin has a gift for blending careful biblical scholarship with humor, humility, and genuine compassion. One of my favorite lines was:
“Jesus instructed us to love our enemies and to do good to those who hate us. Where in that equation is there any room to treat a fellow human being with contempt?”
One of my biggest criticisms of persuasive nonfiction is that it often ends up preaching to people who already agree with its message. While I certainly fall into that camp, I was pleasantly surprised by how broadly this book speaks. Whether you’re an affirming Christian, a non-affirming Christian, someone questioning what the Bible actually says about LGBTQ inclusion, or even a curious atheist interested in the conversation, Martin approaches difficult questions with grace, intellectual honesty, and respect.
This book thoughtfully explores LGBTQ inclusion, transgender identities, biblical interpretation, and the ways churches have responded to these topics without losing sight of the people at the center of the conversation.
One of the most important Christian books I’ve read this year, and one I’ll be recommending often.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Thank you to St. Martin’s Press for the eARC. But What About…? The Most Asked Questions on Faith, the Bible, and LGBTQ Inclusion by Pastor Colby Martin will be published in November.








