Anna Johnston’s debut, The Borrowed Life of Frederick Fife, is one of my favorite books of the last few years—honestly, one of my all-time favorites. I try not to compare an author’s new work to their previous books because styles, tones, and genres can shift. But in this case, I couldn’t help it… and I walked away a little disappointed.
This novel is set in an assisted living facility in Australia—one that isn’t particularly well run—and follows a woman in her late 40s navigating a difficult medical diagnosis. Alongside her is her brother, a retired Michelin-star chef, with whom she shares a fractured relationship. As they spend time together, both are forced to confront the past, reconcile, and face a major secret he’s been keeping from those around him.
There’s a lot to appreciate here. The story is heartfelt, emotional, and ultimately inspiring. The sibling dynamic—especially Griff and Lisa—was a highlight for me, and I really enjoyed watching their relationship evolve. It’s also a strong example of second-chance family fiction, with meaningful themes around forgiveness and connection.
That said, I found myself wishing for the same simplicity and emotional clarity that made Johnston’s first novel so special. This book leans into heavier, more complex themes, and while that adds depth, it also made the story feel less “pure” and a bit harder to fully connect with.
A quick note: there is a trigger warning for medical diagnosis.
Overall, I liked this one, but didn’t quite love it. Still, it’s a solid contemporary read—and one of my favorite covers of 2026!
Thank you to NetGalley and William Morrow for the ARC. This title is set to be published in the U.S. on August 4, 2026
Leave a Reply