Mia was her mom and dad’s gift to each other, and her little sister Cricket was their present to Mia. The story begins as Cricket is playing for the US Women’s soccer Olympic team. Older sister Mia is giving birth at the exact time and watching Cricket play from the hospital. A health emergency occurs. Then the narrative jumps back to their mother Liz Lowe as she is a high school senior who has signed and committed to play for UCLA. It becomes apparent that Liz is pregnant with Mia and her promising soccer career ends abruptly.
What I absolutely loved about this story was the characterization, the relationship and dynamic between Mia and Cricket, the gradual way that the narrative unfolds as we find out more about Mia and Cricket’s absent father, their mother’s love of soccer, and how she passed along being a “team player” to her girls, both named for Women’s soccer legends. Something else I loved was the interlocution of the history of the game of soccer and how it grew in culture. As a fan of women’s soccer I loved this essential part of the story. Cricket, Mia and Liz were WONDERFUL characters, there are also very memorable side characters.
What I didn’t like; in some ways I feel like this book glorifies codependency, but it does show the darker side. I had a professor in college that said “Gilmore Girls” was “anti-choice pro-life propaganda” and I spent hours trying to prove them wrong by highlighting some of Rory’s most pro-feminist and pro-choice identity scenes. But ever since then I have always read into stories about teenagers choosing birth instead of termination with a critical eye, especially in narratives where the child’s father was a predator of some sort. I don’t think this is the case at all, but it did give me a lot to think about. What was a larger theme in this book is the mother and the sister giving up big parts of themselves for the other; without the person asking- so in some ways what you are willing to give up in your life for your daughter or sister.
While some of the setbacks that happen can seem like too much, there is enough drama in all of their years that you are like JEEZ WHAT ELSE CAN HAPPEN TO THESE WOMEN they deserve a break already. It can be bit much at times and you don’t always agree with the decisions of the characters but you still get the feeling that things will work out for them….. particularly because in the prologue about Mia having a baby, you get a lot of what can only be described as spoilers.
This would be a great book for book clubs as it is thought provoking and allows readers to ask questions within a group. The characters are flawed yet likable. This is great for fans of sweeping family dramas like The Celebrants, Blue Sisters, Long Island Compromise and Like Mother Like Mother. Written by a former White House stenographer.
Thanks to NetGalley and Random House/Dial Press for the ARC. Book to be published July 1, 2025.
Leave a Reply