
Woof- I have complicated feelings about this book.
First- Jesse Q Sutanto is one of my absolute favorite authors- see my 5 star review of the Vera Wong books, 5 star review of [book:Next Time Will Be Our Turn|227912363] and the Mulan re-telling [book:Worth Fighting For|217064246].
Second- this book literally says “Goodreads is full of trolls,” yikes, as a “top goodreads reviewer” I am hurt. But I won’t take it personally. It is hard to be an ARC reviewer- part of you wants to give every book 5 stars because you know as an early reviewer your review (even if it is softly critical) has the potential to really swing a title. On the other hand if you are too positive your reviews become meaningless so you need to maintain an objective viewpoint. I’ve been challenged for being both “too mean” and “too nice” so this kind of goes along with the territory.
Third- This is a classic “cat fight” girl vs girl “mean girl” story and I find those to be unfortunate and somewhat misogynistic. I personally don’t love this trope because I think it perpetuates stereotypes. Stories like this make me want to not be close to another woman, ever.
Lastly- I think this will be very successful, just because I am a sensitive baby does not mean others won’t love it. I could not put it down although I was reading while covering my eyes. It’s a great – BUT DARK – story.
Thanks to NetGalley and Mindy’s Books Studio for the ARC. Book to be published 2/3/26








