
Another book about a group of adult siblings that is slowly falling apart. While not as depressing as Long Island Compromise, it is just as funny, and has an atmospheric European island setting that is necessary for the artistic direction. Fans of Blue Sisters and Like Mother, Like Mother will love another world of complicated family relationships.
Netta, Susan, Goose and Iris all have wonderful character development in this novel, their father announcing he is setting aside his lothario ways and getting married to Bella-Mae, a 27 year old who is CERTAINLY not marrying him for his fame and money. A famous artist, Vic suspiciously drowns in the lake shortly after marrying Bella Mae with no will. And what is more, Vic’s last piece of artwork is missing.
This is an easily readable book and the blurb is perfect, it gives away just enough about the plot to engage the reader without giving away too much. The premise, to many, may overshadow the outcome. The reveals throughout the book don’t come as a big splash, but very human and subtle. It ends not with a bang, but with a music box tinkling. Each character is developed and tweaked, just when you think you know who they are, they surprise you and break your heart in the best way.
Then comes the time to separate and take the items from the family home. They use stickers to indicate what items they want, with a number from 1-4 based on how important it is to them. And by then, you know each character so well that they act completely as you’d expect. It is such a good scene and proof of how well developed they are. The character we don’t actually know that well is Bella-Mae, but she is really more of a Maguffin to move the story forward rather than being important herself.
Not everyone will like this one, but I found it to be like listening to an opera…. the goal of an opera is not the ending, but the journey of the music drawing you in. The pacing and characterization are brilliant and I also loved the setting and how it built towards the complete arc of each sibling.
Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for the ARC and for Madison Dettlinger from Random House marketing for recommending this novel. Book to be published June 24, 2025





